Key Takeaways:
- Animal Justice has filed a petition for judicial review in the BC Supreme Court challenging the province’s treatment of industry-written farmed animal welfare standards.
- BC’s Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act protects animals from distress, but provides a defence for reasonable and generally accepted animal management practices.
- BC’s Animal Care Codes of Practice Regulation recognizes requirements and recommendations in specified National Farm Animal Care Council (NFACC) codes of practice for farmed animals as both reasonable and generally accepted.
- Animal Justice believes the regulation is unlawful and removes a critical safeguard against suffering on farms provided by the Act.
- Farmed animals need strong legal protections, not industry self-regulation. Sign this petition to help push for change.
Animal Justice is challenging BC’s Animal Care Codes of Practice Regulation (the “Regulation”) in court to protect farmed animals from extreme suffering. We have filed a petition for judicial review in the BC Supreme Court, arguing that the province acted without legal authority under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act by recognizing industry-written farming standards as not only “generally accepted” but also “reasonable” under the Act.
Animal cruelty laws should protect animals from suffering. Yet across Canada, provincial governments generally rely on industry-written standards developed through the National Farm Animal Care Council (NFACC) to assess the treatment of farmed animals. The Act allows BC to pass regulations respecting “generally accepted” farming practices, but it does not allow regulations to dictate whether those practices are also “reasonable” and therefore exempt from the Act. However, this is exactly what the province has done. BC’s Regulation recognizes NFACC standards as both “generally accepted” and “reasonable”, allowing the agriculture industry to significantly and disproportionately influence the law regarding animal treatment on farms.
The government should not deem cruel practices reasonable just because they are accepted within the farming industry.
Why Animal Justice Is Taking BC to Court
Our judicial review asks the BC Supreme Court to determine whether the government acted within its legal authority under the Act when it created the Regulation. Specifically, we say section 4 of the Regulation is unlawful.
We argue that by recognizing the listed NFACC standards as both reasonable and generally accepted, the province has removed a critical safeguard: the question of whether an industry practice is actually reasonable.
This case tackles a root cause of BC’s failure to protect farmed animals: reliance on industry standards that shield even the cruelest farming practices from animal protection laws.
How Animal Cruelty Laws in Canada Leave Farmed Animals Vulnerable
Canada has no national law setting welfare standards for how animals are housed and treated on farms. Federal welfare standards apply to farmed animals only during transport and slaughter. Provincial animal welfare laws prohibit causing or permitting animals to be in distress, but those laws exempt suffering caused by common agricultural practices, and generally rely on voluntary standards developed through NFACC.
NFACC is a private, industry-led organization that creates “Codes of Practice” for farmed animals. These codes address matters such as housing, handling, and painful procedures.
This industry-led system often prioritizes profits over the well-being of animals. Allowing the industry to shape the standards used to assess its own conduct leaves animals vulnerable to practices that cause extreme suffering.
Under NFACC’s codes, mother pigs can be confined in gestation crates so small they cannot even turn around. Parts of chickens’ sensitive beaks can be cut off without anaesthetic. Calves can be castrated without pain relief. Baby chicks can be ground up alive. Piglets can be killed by being slammed against a concrete wall. These are living, feeling animals, and their pain should not be dismissed simply because the industry accepts the practices that cause it. We don’t allow the oil and gas industry to determine what level of pollution is lawful. Nor do we allow industry to dictate its own workplace safety standards. Yet when it comes to farmed animals, the fox is left to guard the henhouse.
Animal cruelty laws in Canada should provide meaningful protection for farmed animals. Industry acceptance should never be the deciding measure of whether their suffering is reasonable and exempt from the law.

NFACC Codes Shape BC Animal Cruelty Laws
British Columbia’s Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act prohibits causing animals distress. But the Act provides a defence when distress results from “reasonable” and “generally accepted” animal management practices.
With regards to what practices are considered “generally accepted”, the Act allows the government to create regulations respecting “generally accepted” practices. What the Act does NOT allow is for the regulations to determine whether such practices are also reasonable.
Animal Justice argues that the Act, as BC’s primary animal protection law, clearly draws a line between what is generally accepted and what is objectively reasonable. Without this distinction, much of the Act would be rendered effectively meaningless, because a farming practice can be widely accepted within the industry and still be unreasonable due to the suffering it causes.
Yet BC’s Animal Care Codes of Practice Regulation recognizes NFACC codes as both reasonable and generally accepted. We say this undermines the purpose and intent of the Act. Rather than leaving room to objectively assess whether an industry-standard practice is unreasonable, the Regulation gives the listed standards the government’s stamp of approval.
As explained in our blog on Canada’s lack of farm oversight, NFACC has no lawmaking or enforcement powers. Its industry-developed codes are not themselves government-made animal protection laws.
Take Action: Demand Legal Protections for Farmed Animals
Farmed animals deserve laws that put their well-being ahead of industry convenience and profits. Governments should pass their own strong, enforceable animal protection laws instead of relying on industry self-regulation.
Our report, Towards a National Framework for Farmed Animal Protection, outlines a path forward: comprehensive federal legislation, independent standard-setting, dedicated government oversight, and stronger enforcement. Animal Justice’s court challenge is part of our work to secure those critical protections for farmed animals.
Banner: Jo-Anne McArthur | We Animals
Frequently Asked Questions:
Why is Animal Justice taking the BC government to court?
Animal Justice has filed a petition for judicial review in the BC Supreme Court challenging a regulation that recognizes specified industry-written farm animal standards as reasonable and generally accepted. We say the regulation is unlawful and are asking the court to determine whether the government acted within its legal authority.
What is the National Farm Animal Care Council?
The National Farm Animal Care Council, or NFACC, is a private, industry-led organization that creates voluntary Codes of Practice for farmed animals in Canada. Animal Justice criticizes this system for allowing industry interests to shape standards that permit significant animal suffering, including painful procedures and severe confinement. Many NFACC-approved practices have been banned in jurisdictions around the world.
How do BC animal cruelty laws apply to farmed animals?
BC’s Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act protects farmed animals from distress. However, it provides a defence for distress resulting from reasonable and generally accepted animal management practices. A provincial regulation recognizes requirements and recommendations in specified NFACC codes as meeting that test even though the Act only allows regulations to dictate which practices are generally accepted.
“Generally accepted” doesn’t mean “reasonable”?
The wording requires more than industry acceptance. Animal Justice argues that a common farming practice can still be unreasonable because of the suffering it causes. Our challenge concerns the government’s recognition of listed NFACC standards as satisfying both requirements in apparent violation of the Act.
Are there national laws protecting animals on farms in Canada?
Canada has general criminal animal cruelty provisions and federal rules covering areas such as animal transport and slaughter. However, it lacks a comprehensive national law setting welfare standards for animals’ day-to-day housing and treatment on farms. On-farm animal welfare is largely addressed through provincial laws and industry-developed codes.
What could this legal challenge change for farmed animals?
Animal Justice aims to restore a meaningful safeguard against farming practices that are unreasonable, yet accepted by industry. The outcome will depend on the court’s decision. Our broader goal is stronger government-made protections for farmed animals.
How can I help strengthen animal cruelty laws?
Sign the petition to support the campaign for stronger laws for farmed animals and help push governments to take responsibility for their protection.